Ben Epstein Director, Screenwriter, Producer Ema Horvath Alex Actor Devon Sawa Karl Actor Alyssa Milano Judith Actor, Executive Producer John Ales Carey Actor Yeardley Smith Sarah Actor, Executive Producer Peter Parros Reggie Actor Siddharth Dhananjay Rohan Actor Reid Miller Arthur Actor Jordan Foley Producer Toby Louie Producer Nick Smith Producer Graham Moore Executive Producer Ben Cornwell Executive Producer Fred Chandler Executive Producer Neely Eisenstein Executive Producer, Casting A.J. Gordon Executive Producer Robert Lam Cinematographer, Casting Jeff Bernier Film Editing Aaron Zigman Original Music Sean Roney Production Design Ryan Lloyd Set Decoration Julie Carnahan Costume Design