Candace Cameron Bure Aurora Teagarden Actor, Executive Producer Skyler Samuels Aurora Actor Lexa Doig Sally Allison Actor Evan Roderick Arthur Actor Marilu Henner Aida Teagarden Actor Bruce Dawson John Queensland Actor Peter Benson Arthur Smith Actor Miranda Frigon Lynn Liggett-Smith Actor Niall Matter Nick Miller Actor Ellie Harvie Lillian Tibbett Actor David Ingram Macon Turner Guest Star Julian Christopher LeMaster Cane Guest Star Craig March Captain Burns Guest Star Dave Collette Bubba Rankart Guest Star Yannick Bisson Martin Bartell Guest Star Darla Fay Maisie Schlumper Guest Star Scott Lyster Perry Dell Guest Star Catherine Lough Haggquist Terry Sternholtz Guest Star James Rittinger Jason Dell Guest Star Brad Harder Officer Heard Guest Star Martin Wood Director Terry Ingram Director Lynne Stopkewich Director Kevin Fair Director Jamie Goehring Producer, Executive Producer Jim Head Executive Producer Charlaine Harris Writer, Writer, Executive Producer Trevor McWhinney Producer Teena Booth Writer Shelley Evans Writer Shawn Williamson Executive Producer Michael Prupas Executive Producer Joel S. Rice Executive Producer Jessica Harmon Director