Jonathan Silver Scott Self Drew Scott Self JD Scott Host David Bromstad Judge Egypt Sherrod Judge Tiffany Brooks Judge Eric Bennett Judge Lindsey Bennett Judge Karen Jensen Judge Mina Starsiak Hawk Judge Ben Sargent Judge Brett Waterman Judge Lex LeBlanc Judge Alana LeBlanc Judge Anthony Carrino Judge John Colaneri Judge Vanilla Ice Judge Hilary Farr Judge David Visentin Judge Jen Hatmaker Judge Brandon Hatmaker Judge Josh Temple Judge Tarek El Moussa Judge Christina Haack Judge Mary Beth Anderson Executive Producer Josie Crimi Executive Producer