Michael Weatherly Dr. Jason Bull Actor Freddy Rodríguez Benny Colón Actor Geneva Carr Marissa Morgan Actor Jaime Lee Kirchner Danny James Actor Annabelle Attanasio Cable McCrory Actor Chris Jackson Chunk Palmer Actor Dana Delany Sylvia Banner Guest Star Emily Tremaine Fernandez Laura Anthony Guest Star Lizbeth MacKay Teresa Anthony Guest Star Mehdi Barakchian Kevin Guest Star Jordan Dean State Trooper Stevens Guest Star Patrick Cooley Martin Guest Star Vinny Anand Police Officer Guest Star Bill Raymond Judge Jessup Guest Star Vickie Warehime Potential Juror 2 Guest Star Christine Renee Miller Lynn Guest Star Geoffrey Cantor Dr. Kulkarni Guest Star Joey Rippo Nicholas Allen Guest Star Brian Hotaling Dr. Yates Guest Star Lenny Delgado Priest Guest Star Jordan Carey State Trooper Guest Star Stephanie Weppler Potential Juror 1 Guest Star Mary Theresa Archbold NYCCS Worker Guest Star Paul Attanasio Executive Producer Phil McGraw Executive Producer Jay McGraw Executive Producer Justin Falvey Executive Producer Darryl Frank Executive Producer Erica Peterson Writer Bethany Rooney Director