Michael Urie Host Martha Stewart Judge Chris Lambton Judge Fernando Wong Judge Mike "Gibby Sciz" Gibson Contestant Edward "Cowboy" Pequignot Contestant Meghan Petricka Contestant Jade Rojas Contestant Juan Villanueva Contestant Marie Danielle Vil-Young Contestant Ryan Zoeller Contestant Joseph Eardly Producer Elli Hakami Producer Danny Salles Producer Ella Grossbach Producer