Hudson Oz Narrator Jared Dante Thomas Nicholson Actor Jarod Lindsey Patron Actor Martin Pfefferkorn Claude Hill Actor Danish Farooqui Ball Player Actor Sophia VanDette Cerenati Actor Laurel Kornfeld Victim's Aunt Actor Joan Chak Lee Henry Actor Hannah Savage Natasha Actor Rachel Gold Lindsey Wilkins Actor Stuart Matthews Vaughn Estes Actor Emma Giorgio School Kid Actor Maya Allicock Valerie Bratten Actor Hassan Farrow Patron #5 Actor Lluvia Almanza Whitney's Friend Actor Drew Schrum Justin Jensen Actor W.A.R. Police Officer Actor Samantha Evans Whitney Bennett Actor Andrea Ilene Shapiro Cheyenne Clough Actor Amanda Leigh Bell Nicholson's Girlfriend Actor Allison Corn Executive Producer Stan Hsue Executive Producer Stephen McLaughlin Executive Producer Jennifer Silverman Executive Producer Antony Tackaberry Executive Producer Beth Spitalny Director Andrea De Brito Director