Krysten Ritter Chloe Actor Dreama Walker June Actor Mookie Blaiklock Eli Actor Eric André Mark Actor Ray Ford Luther Actor James Van Der Beek James Van Der Beek Actor Ben Lawson Guest Star Michael Stahl-David Guest Star Annie Little Guest Star Mickey Maxwell Guest Star Sara Van Horn Guest Star Paula Eliott Guest Star Cinton Emmanuel Guest Star Jordan Feldman Guest Star Maurice Webster Guest Star Teresa Huang Guest Star Nahnatchka Khan Executive Producer David Hemingson Executive Producer Jeffrey Morton Executive Producer Billy Finnegan Writer Gail Mancuso Director