Billy Porter Narrator Alexandra Grey Lucy Hicks Anderson Actor Anne Ramsay FBI Agent Actor Anthony Rapp Harry Hay Actor Cheyenne Jackson Dale Jennings Actor Cole Doman Mark Segal Actor Elizabeth Ludlow Stormé DeLarverie Actor Gale Harold Howard Smith Actor Hailie Sahar Sylvia Rivera Actor Heather Matarazzo Phyllis Lyon Actor Isis King Alexis Actor Jai Rodriguez José Sarria Actor Jamie Clayton Christine Jorgensen Actor Keiynan Lonsdale Bayard Rustin Actor Sam Pancake Dick Leitsch Actor Samira Wiley Lorraine Hannsberry Actor Sara Gilbert J.M. From Cleveland Actor Scott T. Schofield Craig Rodwell Actor Shannon Purser Del Martin Actor Theo Germaine Jack Starr Actor Brooke Karzen Executive Producer David Collins Executive Producer Eric Norsoph Executive Producer Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Jim Parsons Executive Producer Jon Jashni Executive Producer Michael Williams Executive Producer Mike Darnell Executive Producer Rob Eric Executive Producer Sarah Schechter Executive Producer Todd Spiewak Executive Producer Joel Chiodi Executive Producer