McKenzie Westmore Host Ve Neill Judge Glenn Hetrick Judge Neville Page Judge Patrick Tatopoulos Judge Carpucine "C.C." Childs Contestant Nicole Chilelli Contestant Derek Garcia Contestant Eric Garcia Contestant Rod Maxwell Contestant Jason Milani Contestant Sarah Miller Contestant Thomas Pietch Contestant Alana Rose Schiro Contestant Laura Tyler Contestant Roy Wooley Contestant Silas Weir Mitchell Guest Paul W.S. Anderson Judge Gale Anne Hurd Judge Kevin Smith Judge Michael Agbabian Executive Producer Dwight D. Smith Executive Producer Derek Atherton Executive Producer