Louise Roe Host Jessica Simpson Self Nicole Richie Self John Varvatos Self Caprice Willard Judge Terron E. Schaefer Judge Erika De Salvatore Judge David Appel Contestant Silvia Arguello Contestant Hunter Bell Contestant Priscilla Barroso Contestant Johana Hernandez Contestant Cassandra Hobbins Contestant Tori Nichel Contestant Amber Perley Contestant Brandon Scott Contestant Daniel Silverstein Contestant Bret Young Contestant JesseRay Vasquez Contestant Garrett Gerson Contestant Nicole Christie Judge Elle Macpherson Host, Executive Producer Ben Silverman Executive Producer Jane Lipsitz Executive Producer Dan Cutforth Executive Producer Rick Ringbakk Executive Producer E.J. Johnston Executive Producer James Deutch Executive Producer