Brandon Micheal Hall Miles Finer Actor Violett Beane Cara Bloom Actor Joe Morton Reverend Arthur Finer Actor Suraj Sharma Rakesh Singh Actor Javicia Leslie Ali Finer Actor Rachel Bay Jones Susan Guest Star Shazi Raja Jaya Guest Star Eleanor Koski Liv Guest Star Dawn-Lyen Gardner Katie Guest Star Ajay Naidu Eric Guest Star James Georgiades Manager Guest Star Christopher Halladay Shop Owner Guest Star Flor De Liz Perez Natalie Guest Star Caleb Clark Nate Guest Star Steven Lilien Executive Producer, Writer Bryan Wynbrandt Executive Producer, Writer Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Sarah Schechter Executive Producer Marcos Siega Executive Producer, Director