Paula Poundstone Voice, Writer Brendon Small Voice, Writer H. Jon Benjamin Voice, Writer Melissa Bardin Galsky Voice, Writer Ron Lynch Guest Voice Paula Plum Guest Voice Lara Silverman Guest Voice Emo Philips Guest Voice Sam Brown Guest Voice Richard Snee Guest Voice Eugene Mirman Guest Voice Mitch Hedberg Guest Voice Mitch Hedber Guest Voice Tom Snyder Executive Producer Loren Bouchard Executive Producer, Director, Writer Mary Catherine Tucker Executive Producer Bonnie Burns Executive Producer