David Weil Creator Al Pacino Meyer Offerman Actor Logan Lerman Jonah Heidelbaum Actor Jerrika Hinton Millie Malone Actor Josh Radnor Lonny Flash Actor Kate Mulvany Sister Harriet Actor Tiffany Boone Roxy Jones Actor Greg Austin Travis Leich Actor Louis Ozawa Joe Torrance Actor Carol Kane Mindy Markowitz Actor Saul Rubinek Murray Markowitz Actor Dylan Baker Biff Simpson Actor Lena Olin The Colonel Actor Jennifer Jason Leigh Chava Apfelbaum Actor Jordan Peele Executive Producer Nikki Toscano Executive Producer Alfonso Gomez-Rejon Executive Producer Win Rosenfeld Executive Producer Nelson McCormick Executive Producer Tom Lesinski Executive Producer