Andrea Savage Andrea Creator, Actor, Executive Producer Tom Everett Scott Mike Actor Olive Petrucci Amelia Actor Kathy Baker Guest Star Allison Tolman Guest Star Nelson Franklin Guest Star Gary Anthony Williams Guest Star Martin Mull Guest Star Julia Cho Guest Star Eugene Cordero Guest Star Scott Aukerman Guest Star Jamie Kaler Guest Star Lennon Parham Guest Star Shelly Slocum Guest Star Brian Stepanek Guest Star Jennie Pierson Guest Star David Nathan Schwartz Guest Star Destiny Mariah Ochoa Guest Star Carrie Madsen Guest Star Bill Lewis Guest Star Joey Slamon Executive Producer Jessica Elbaum Executive Producer Will Ferrell Executive Producer Adam McKay Executive Producer Jason Zaro Executive Producer Billy Rosenberg Executive Producer Andy Samberg Executive Producer Jorma Taccone Executive Producer Akiva Schaffer Executive Producer