Mikey Day Host Chrishell Stause Judge Chris Witaske Judge Nico Santos Judge Brandon Kyle Goodman Judge Anna Camp Judge Heidi D'Amelio Judge Cristela Alonzo Judge Kirby Judge Melissa Villaseñor Judge Chiney Ogwumike Judge Chris Redd Judge Blake Anderson Judge Joel McHale Judge Joel Kim Booster Judge Maz Jobrani Judge Ally Love Judge Chloe Fineman Judge Kate Flannery Judge Taylor Tomlinson Judge Michael Tiberi Producer Cat Sullivan Executive Producer Rich Kim Director