Hannah Simone Host John McPhee Contestant Nakeisha Turk Contestant Jason White Contestant Elaine Swann Contestant Ras Vaughan Contestant Kristen Erskine Contestant Ben Domian Contestant Juliana Herz Contestant Terry Fossum Contestant Natalie Casanova Contestant Caleb Garmany Contestant Sam Shankland Contestant Brady Cervantes Contestant Angelica Bridges Contestant Hakim Isler Contestant Claire Schreiner Contestant Tamra Hyde Contestant Maxwell Carr Contestant Jessie Krebs Contestant Michael Forbs Contestant Matt Kunitz Executive Producer Anthony Dominici Executive Producer