Tim Roth Dr. Cal Lightman Actor Kelli Williams Dr. Gillian Foster Actor Monica Raymund Ria Torres Actor Brendan Hines Eli Loker Actor Mekhi Phifer FBI Agent Ben Reynolds Actor Hayley McFarland Emily Lightman Actor Chad L. Coleman Darryl Guest Star Christopher Thornton Johnny Wheels Guest Star Conor O'Farrell Bernard Dillon Guest Star Ivo Nandi Churlish Guest Star Jack McGee Old Timer Guest Star Christopher Darga Big Brother Guest Star Lindsey Kraft Connie Guest Star Maury Sterling Sully Guest Star Michael McGrady Gil Wallace Guest Star Noel Fisher Brian Warner Guest Star Jennifer Marsala Anna Guest Star Ronnie Gene Blevins Hoodak Guest Star Samuel Baum Executive Producer Brian Grazer Executive Producer Shawn Ryan Executive Producer Samantha Howard Corbin Writer Seith Mann Director