François Arnaud Manfred Bernardo Actor Dylan Bruce Bobo Winthrop Actor Parisa Fitz-Henley Fiji Cavanaugh Actor Arielle Kebbel Olivia Charity Actor Sarah Ramos Creek Lovell Actor Peter Mensah Lemuel Bridger Actor Yul Vazquez Rev. Emilio Sheehan Actor Jason Lewis Joe Strong Actor Challen Cates Melanie Pratt Guest Star Ryan McCartan Jeremy Guest Star Derek Mears Colconnar Guest Star Bernardo Gallegos Chuy Strong Guest Star Kellee Stewart Madonna Reed Guest Star Joe Smith Voice of Mr. Snuggly Guest Voice Monica Owusu-Breen Executive Producer David Janollari Executive Producer Niels Arden Oplev Executive Producer