Jim Caviezel John Reese Actor Michael Emerson Harold Finch Actor Taraji P. Henson Joss Carter Actor Kevin Chapman Lionel Fusco Actor Vincent Laresca Detective Molina Guest Star Susan Misner Jessica Arndt Guest Star James Carpinello Joey Durban Guest Star Keith Nobbs Straub Guest Star Akintola Jiboyewa Teddy Guest Star Rey Lucas Willis Guest Star Ruben Santiago-Hudson Sam Latimer Guest Star Lili Mirojnick Pia Moresco Guest Star José Ramón Rosario Cop Guest Star Rick Zahn Police Officer Guest Star Elizabeth Masucci Stacey Guest Star Charles Borland Businessman 1 Guest Star Gregory Jones Businessman 2 Guest Star J.J. Abrams Executive Producer Bryan Burk Executive Producer Jonathan Nolan Executive Producer David Semel Executive Producer Greg Plageman Executive Producer Patrick Harbinson Writer Steven DePaul Director