Janet Montgomery Mary Sibley Actor Shane West John Alden Actor Seth Gabel Cotton Mather Actor Ashley Madekwe Tituba Actor Tamzin Merchant Anne Hale Actor Elise Eberle Mercy Lewis Actor Xander Berkeley Magistrate Hale Actor Iddo Goldberg Isaac Walton Guest Star Samantha Hanratty Dollie Trask Guest Star Azure Parsons Gloriana Guest Star Stephen Lang Increase Mather Guest Star Lara Grice Mrs. Hale Guest Star Rachel Whitman Groves Mrs. Trask Guest Star Melanie Haynes Neighbor 2 Guest Star Daniel James Joe Barker Guest Star David Jensen Captain Guest Star Sharon Landry Mrs. Barker Guest Star Benjamin Mouton Lamb Guest Star Morgana Shaw Mab Guest Star Lance Eakright Militia on horseback Guest Star Michael P Gardner Militia Man Guest Star Michelle Harvey Flashing Puritan Guest Star Laney Kate Hulbert Laundress Child Guest Star Mary Hulbert Merchant Child Guest Star R. Todd Jones Lamb's Publick House Bartender Guest Star Justin Lebrun Militia, Zombie Guest Star Gregory Nye Selectman Guest Star Bruce Roberts Selectman Guest Star Lindsey Roberts Ship Passenger, Townsperson Guest Star Jeremy Summers Selectman Guest Star Adam Simon Executive Producer Brannon Braga Executive Producer Josh S. Barry Executive Producer Jeff Kwatinetz Executive Producer