Tom Mison Ichabod Crane Actor Nicole Beharie Lt. Abbie Mills Actor Lyndie Greenwood Jenny Mills Actor Shannyn Sossamon Guest Star Zach Appelman Guest Star Chris Bert Guest Star Jessica Camacho Guest Star Maya Kazan Guest Star Lance Gross Guest Star Andy Pessoa Guest Star Lindsay Ayliffe Guest Star Autumn Dial Guest Star James Donadio Guest Star Anthony K. Hyatt Guest Star Paul B. Johnson Guest Star Jon Kohler Guest Star Angela Ray Guest Star Cody Robinson Guest Star Mykee Selkin Guest Star Alex Sgambati Guest Star Josh Ventura Guest Star Alex Kurtzman Executive Producer Roberto Orci Executive Producer Len Wiseman Executive Producer Heather Kadin Executive Producer