Jeremy Sisto George Altman Actor Jane Levy Tessa Altman Actor Carly Chaikin Dalia Royce Actor Rex Lee Mr. Wolfe Actor Allie Grant Lisa Shay Actor Alan Tudyk Noah Werner Actor Chris Parnell Fred Shay Actor Ana Gasteyer Sheila Shay Actor Cheryl Hines Dallas Royce Actor Parker Young Guest Star Maestro Harrell Guest Star Abbie Cobb Guest Star Bunnie Rivera Guest Star Malin Akerman Guest Star Al Carabello Guest Star Gillian Vigman Guest Star Dyana Liu Guest Star Derek Waters Guest Star Paula Newsome Guest Star Tim Meadows Guest Star Tiffany Boone Guest Star Maxine Weldon Guest Star Monnae Michaell Guest Star Emily Kapnek Executive Producer, Writer Julie Anne Robinson Director