Justin Spitzer Creator, Executive Producer America Ferrera Amy Actor, Producer Ben Feldman Jonah Actor Mark McKinney Glenn Actor Lauren Ash Dina Actor Colton Dunn Garrett Actor Nichole Sakura Cheyenne Actor Nico Santos Mateo Actor Cecily Strong Missy Jones Guest Star Apolo Ohno Apolo Anton Ohno Guest Star Tara Lipinski Tara Lipinski Guest Star McKayla Maroney McKayla Maroney Guest Star Linda Porter Myrtle Vartanian Guest Star Kelly Schumann Justine Sikowicz Guest Star David Bernad Executive Producer Ruben Fleischer Executive Producer Gabe Miller Executive Producer Jonathan Green Executive Producer