Crystal Reed Abby Arcane Actor Andy Bean Alec Holland Actor Derek Mears Swamp Thing Actor Virginia Madsen Maria Sunderland Actor Henderson Wade Matt Cable Actor Maria Sten Liz Tremayne Actor Will Patton Avery Sunderland Actor Jeryl Prescott Madame Xanadu Actor Jennifer Beals Sheriff Lucilia Cable Actor Kevin Durand Jason Woodrue Actor Ian Ziering Daniel Cassidy Guest Star Leonardo Nam Harlan Edwards Guest Star Macon Blair Phantom Stranger Guest Star Michael Beach Nathan Ellery Guest Star Given Sharp Shawna Sunderland Guest Star Elle Graham Susie Coyle Guest Star Selena Anduze Caroline Woodrue Guest Star Steve Wilcox Burritt Sunderland Guest Star Al Mitchell Delroy Tremayne Guest Star Charline St. Charles Karen Matthews Guest Star James Wan Executive Producer Mark Verheiden Executive Producer, Writer Gary Dauberman Executive Producer, Writer Michael Clear Executive Producer Len Wiseman Executive Producer, Director Rob Fresco Writer Erin Maher Writer Toa Fraser Director Franklin Rho Writer Kay Reindl Writer Doris Egan Writer Deran Serafian Director Greg Beeman Director E.L. Katz Director Carol Banker Director Alexis Ostrander Director Conway Preston Writer