Alison Sweeney Host Jordan Alicandro Contestant Rondalee Beardslee Contestant Blake Benge Contestant Howard "Woody" Carter Contestant Toma Dobrosavljevic Contestant Zina Garrison Contestant Rob Guiry Contestant Gina Haddon Contestant Lori Harrigan-Mack Contestant Vanessa Hayden Contestant Sonya Jones Contestant Chandra Maple Contestant Matthew Miller Contestant Scott Mitchell Contestant Emmy Lou Munoz Contestant Mike Murburg Contestant John "J.J." O'Malley Contestant Jackie Pierson Contestant Andrea Wilamowski Contestant Damien Woody Contestant Jenna Wolfe Guest Star Ben Silverman Executive Producer David Broome Executive Producer Todd Lubin Executive Producer Lisa Hennessy Executive Producer Eden Gaha Executive Producer J.D. Roth Executive Producer Todd Nelson Executive Producer