Seth Meyers Prock Voice, Executive Producer Taran Killam Frantic Voice Steve Higgins Mr. Awesome Voice Paula Pell Gadget Gal Voice Ike Barinholtz Muscleman Voice Rashida Jones Hotwire, Metal Fella Voice Bill Hader Dr. Malocchio Voice Kenan Thompson The Impresario Voice Bobby Lee Sumo Voice Josh Meyers Perfect Man Voice Emily Spivey Concierge Voice Amy Poehler Jaclyn Stone Actor Maya Rudolph Lady Malocchio Actor Will Forte Malocchio Jr. Actor Fred Armisen Guest Voice Vanessa Bayer Guest Voice Michael Shoemaker Executive Producer