Minnie Driver Sarah Actor Natacha Karam Hagar Actor Jeffrey Donovan Abraham Actor Alexa Davalos Rebekah Guest Star Tom Mison Isaac Guest Star Tom Payne Jacob Guest Star Ben Robson Esau Guest Star Lars Bethke Bethuel Guest Star Corinne Jaber Milcah Guest Star Nathan Altai Eliezer Guest Star Sarah Belcher Deborah Guest Star Lynn Swanson Midwife #2 Guest Star Rob Davidson teen Esau Guest Star Jacopo Dragonetti Hunter Guest Star Jessica Zhao Neela Guest Star Douglas Dean Healer Guest Star Mattia Sonnino Shepherd Jabir Guest Star Simone Moretto Herdsman Guest Star Nathan Dean Williams E'lon Guest Star Lyna Dubarry A'dah Guest Star Matteo Piombino Young Laban Guest Star Ercan Karakayli Traveling Merchant Guest Star Daisy Tennant Midwife Guest Star Roisin Mcternan young Rebekah Guest Star Levi-James McDonagh young Jacob Guest Star Ercan Sarah Belcher Deborah Guest Star Tommaso Miragoli Shepherd Obed Guest Star Daniel Varbanov Simon Guest Star Meghane De Croock Hittite Woman Guest Star Elisabeth Yorke Female Petitioner Guest Star Damiano Lauria Eli'Phaz Guest Star Calum Michael Jess teen Jacob Guest Star Millie Brady Actor Carol Mendelsohn Executive Producer Julie Weitz Executive Producer René Echevarria Executive Producer Danny Cannon Director