Martha Plimpton Eileen Actor Jay R. Ferguson Pat Actor Noah Galvin Kenny Actor Matt Shively Jimmy Actor Bebe Wood Shannon Actor Mary Hollis Inboden Jodi Actor Cheyenne Jackson Mr. Peters Guest Star Matt Oberg VP Murray Guest Star Ray Ford Steve Guest Star Brian Huskey Father Phil Guest Star Rick Fitts Bishop Callahan Guest Star Jessica Pohly Ms. Dunn Guest Star Allyson Nicole Jones Student Guest Star David Windsor Executive Producer Casey Johnson Executive Producer Brian Pines Executive Producer Dan McDermott Executive Producer Stacy Traub Executive Producer Dan Savage Executive Producer Todd Holland Executive Producer Lorenzo di Bonaventura Executive Producer Adam Roberts Writer Jaffar Mahmood Director