Nina Dobrev Elena Gilbert Actor Paul Wesley Stefan Salvatore Actor Ian Somerhalder Damon Salvatore Actor Steven R McQueen Jeremy Gilbert Actor Sara Canning Jenna Somers Actor Kat Graham Bonnie Bennett Actor Candice King Caroline Forbes Actor Zach Roerig Matt Donovan Actor Kayla Ewell Vicki Donovan Actor Michael Trevino Tyler Lockwood Actor Arielle Kebbel Lexi Branson Guest Star Marguerite MacIntyre Liz Forbes Guest Star Bianca Lawson Emily Bennett Guest Star Jasmine Guy Sheila Bennett Guest Star Jasmine Burke Birdie Mae Guest Star Bridget Evelyn Girl Guest Star John Gilbert Guy Guest Star Jason Giuliano Deputy #2 Guest Star Kevin Nichols Deputy #1 Guest Star John Michael Weatherly Bartender Guest Star Joshua Haire High School Student Guest Star Charlie Johnson XIV Coven Witch Guest Star Kevin Williamson Executive Producer Julie Plec Executive Producer Leslie Morganstein Executive Producer Bob Levy Executive Producer Rick Bota Director Barbie Kligman Writer Gabrielle G. Stanton Writer