Carson Kressley Host Vanessa Lachey Host Beth Stern Judge Amy Schmoldt Contestant Erika Othen Contestant Liz Parada Contestant Michelle Mozek Contestant Regina Villano Contestant Craig Franczyk Contestant David Lawrence Palmer Contestant JD Scott Contestant Michael Allen Contestant Taylor Bills Contestant Penn & Teller Guest Star Tyra Banks Executive Producer Ashton Kutcher Executive Producer Denise Cramsey Executive Producer Laura Armstrong Executive Producer Jason Goldberg Executive Producer Karey Burke Executive Producer Rod Aissa Executive Producer