Ellie Kemper Kimmy Actor Jane Krakowski Jacqueline Vorhees Actor Tituss Burgess Titus Actor Lauren Adams Gretchen Actor Sara Chase Cyndee Actor Sol Miranda Donna Maria Actor Carol Kane Lillian Actor Dylan Gelula Xanthippe Actor Tina Fey Executive Producer Robert Carlock Executive Producer Jeff Richmond Executive Producer Jack Burditt Executive Producer David Miner Executive Producer