Barry Watson Brian Davis Actor Matthew Davis Adam Hillman Actor Sarah Lancaster Dr. Marjorie Seaver Actor Rick Gomez Dave Greco Actor Amanda Detmer Deena Greco Actor Rosanna Arquette Nicole "Nikki" Varzi Actor Raoul Bova Angelo Varzi Actor Jason George Jimmy Actor Amanda Foreman Ivy Actor William Devane Michael Davis Guest Star Marguerite Moreau Suzanne Guest Star Amy Jo Johnson Karen - Car Girl Guest Star Rachelle Lefevre Summer Guest Star Payton Spencer Geneva Guest Star Mikaila Baumel Larissa Guest Star John Fleck Dr. Bill Guest Star Whitney Cummings Sally Guest Star Sharon Brathwaite-Sanders Bank Employee Guest Star Loren Chase Assistant Guest Star Dana Stevens Executive Producer J.J. Abrams Executive Producer Jeff Judah Executive Producer Gabe Sachs Executive Producer Thom Sherman Executive Producer Bryan Burk Executive Producer Liz Tigelaar Writer Michael Apted Director