Errol Morris Director Lou Diamond Phillips Officer Jim Chee Actor Fred Ward Lieutenant Joe Leaphorn Actor Gary Farmer Cowboy Albert Dashee Actor John Karlen Jake West Actor Lance Baker Mr. Archer Actor Gary Basaraba Larry Actor Arlene Bowman Edna Nezzie Actor Jane Loranger Gail Pauling Actor James Koots Taylor Actor Neil Kayquoptewa Lomatewa Actor Guy Boyd Agent Johnson Actor Robert Redford Executive Producer Bonni Lee Executive Producer Patrick Markey Producer