Harold Cronk Director Melissa Joan Hart Grace Wesley Actor Jesse Metcalfe Tom Endler Actor David A.R. White Rev. Dave Actor, Producer Ernie Hudson Judge Stennis Actor Hayley Orrantia Brooke Thawley Actor Robin Givens Principal Kinney Actor Fred Dalton Thompson Senior Pastor Actor Maria Canals-Barrera Catherine Thawley Actor Sadie Carroway Robertson Huff Marlene Actor Pat Boone Walter Wesley Actor Ray Wise Pete Kane Actor Chuck Konzelman Screenwriter Cary Solomon Screenwriter Michael Scott Producer Russell Wolfe Producer Elizabeth Travis Producer Brittany Yost Producer Troy Duhon Executive Producer Robert Katz Executive Producer Brian Shanley Cinematographer Vance Null Film Editing Wynton Payne Film Editing Will Musser Original Music Mitchell Crisp Production Design Cami Nemanich Costume Design Billy DaMota Casting Dea Vise Casting