Mark Griffiths Director Erin Cottrell Missie LaHaye Actor Dale Midkiff Clark Davis Actor Victor Browne Sheriff Zach Tyler Actor Samantha Smith Marty Davis Actor Holliston Coleman Belinda Marshall Actor Brett Coker Mattie LaHaye Actor Hank Stratton Pastor Joe Actor Braeden Lemasters Jacob Marshall Actor Stephanie Nash Mrs. Pettis Actor Dave Florek Hank Pettis Actor Bret Loehr Calvin Actor Tanner Richie Simon Stevens Actor Ned Schmidtke Hendricks Actor Dale Waddington Mrs. Behringer Actor Ken Magee Mr. Anderson Actor Trevor Gordon Joseph Actor Tyler Gordon Aaron Actor Andre Alexsen Cowboy , Square dancer Actor Jeremy Shada Boy in Stagecoach Actor Lyndon Smith Boy Actor Pamela Wallace Screenwriter Brian Gordon Producer Erik Olson Producer Robert A. Halmi Executive Producer Larry Levinson Executive Producer Brian Shanley Cinematographer Colleen Halsey Film Editing Kevin Kiner Original Music