The Miracle Woman (1931) - Rotten Tomatoes

The Miracle Woman1931

The Miracle Woman (1931)

TOMATOMETER

——

AUDIENCE SCORE

Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

The Miracle Woman Photos

Movie Info

Convinced by her unscrupulous promoters that she's got the true power to heal, an impassioned female evangelist rises to the top then falls in love with a blind aviator, causing her handlers to meddle with her personal life. One of Frank Capra's most outstanding early talkies with memorable, dynamic Barbara Stanwyck.

Cast

Barbara Stanwyck
as Florence "Faith" Fallon
David Manners
as John Carson
Sam Hardy
as Bob Hornsby
Beryl Mercer
as Mrs. Higgins
Russell Hopton
as Sam Welford
Eddie Boland
as Collins
Harry Todd
as Briggs
Edward J. Le Saint
as Parishioner
Ivan Linow
as Gunboat
John Kelly
as Stagehand
Dennis O'Keefe
as Man in Audience
Fred Warren
as Pianist
Mary Doran
as Party Guest
View All

Critic Reviews for The Miracle Woman

All Critics (7)

A surprisingly darker film than most of those for 'feel good' filmmaker Frank Capra.

August 1, 2014 | Rating: B+ | Full Review…

Absorbing

December 29, 2013 | Full Review…

Effective melodrama, with a strong performance from Stanwyck

August 12, 2004 | Rating: 4/5

Early Capra effort with a strong indictment of evangelists still has a lot of power.

March 9, 2004 | Rating: 4/5

Audience Reviews for The Miracle Woman

Barbara Stanwck really lets loose with her frustration and anger in this film's opening scene, as only she could. As she rails at the congregation from a pulpit, a reverend stands in the crowd and implores her to remember she's in the house of God. "What God? Who's God? Yours? This isn't a house of God! It's a meeting-place for hyporcrites!" she screams in reply. Now, it is a little hard to believe when she then turns around and becomes a hypocrite herself, under the guidance of a con-man played well by Sam Hardy. The scenes of her evangelizing to the masses and over the radio are a little slow at first, but the film grew on me. What really makes it is Stanwyck falling for a blind man (David Manners) who was helped by one of her sermons. The scenes between the two are charming and romantic, including him doing some ventriloquism so that he can have his dummy express his feelings, and her playfully singing "The Farmer in the Dell" in a funny voice and breaking up laughing. That bit is so naturally it seems like we're seeing Stanwyck in her home, impromptu. She also sends him letters made with cut-out, raised letters so he can read them, which I thought was touching. David Manners is reasonably good at playing blind, and seems to get better as the film goes on, keeping up with Stanwyck. Frank Capra is a great director, and uses interesting camera angles, slow pans to show a character's gaze, and cuts to minor characters making comments about what they (and we) are seeing. He can really put a finger on what touches us, for example, when Manners elaborately prepares himself so that he can pretend he's got his vision back, but Stanwyck eventually sees through him. Capra also builds to dramatic moments towards the end, though he's unfortunately heavy-handed in the expressions of 'true faith'. I'm not a big fan of that, but for me, the film is a love story, and about the miracle of love, more than anything else.

Antonius Block
Antonius Block

Super Reviewer

½

a cynical capra film inspired by notorious evangelist aimee semple macpherson. a very young barbara stanwyck is great in one of her best early roles. it's similar in tone and plot to elmer gantry, another great film about religious hucksters based on macpherson, who lost most of her flock after faking her own kidnapping in 1926. you can tell this is precode as someone gets the bird lol

Stella Dallas
Stella Dallas

Super Reviewer

The Miracle Woman Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

News & Features