Dana Adam Shapiro Director, Screenwriter, Producer Chris Messina Theo Actor Rashida Jones Nat Actor Meital Dohan Subgirl Actor Zak Orth Quinny Actor Ivan Martin Will Actor Madison Arnold Mr. Margolin Actor Sarah Burns Ella Actor Paul Diomede Man Actor Neal Huff Dr. Gleeman Actor Hannah Gilli Hannah Actor Evan M. Wiener Screenwriter Tom Heller Producer Jeffrey V. Mandel Producer Randy Manis Producer Tim Duff Executive Producer Chuck Goodgal Executive Producer Doug Emmett Cinematographer Jamie Saft Original Music Mollie Goldstein Film Editing Jeremy L. Kotin Film Editing Timothy Whidbee Production Design Jeanelle Marie Art Director Lisa Hennessey Costume Design Billy Hopkins Casting Jessica Kelly Casting