David Mackay Director Hilarie Burton Krissy Kringle Actor Matt Dallas Lance Leigh Actor Gabriel Tigerman Marco Webb Actor Meredith Baxter Carol Kringle Actor Michael Gross Walter Kringle Actor Jessica Tuck Debbie O'Brien Actor Tony Cavalero Justin Reid Actor Michelle Hurd Helen Purcell Actor Danneel Ackles Jill Rhodes Actor Dana Barron Brenda Weir Actor Googy Gress Santa Claus Actor Steven Christopher Parker Peter Actor Kaden Gibson Feisty Kid Actor Tony Denman Cashier Actor Anita Finlay Mrs. Harris Actor Beth Harvey Mother Actor Connor Rosen Daniel Actor Emily Arlook Brittany Actor Sarena Khan Tiffany Actor Candace Bender Jane Ley Actor Mary Scholz Receptionist Actor Stewart Scott Stewie Actor Wade Williams Bill Actor Rickie Castaneda Screenwriter Michael M. McGuire Producer John Murlowski Producer, Cinematographer Scott A. Anderson Executive Producer Timothy O. Johnson Executive Producer Michael Vickerman Executive Producer Daniel Raj Koobir Film Editing Russ Howard III Original Music Lindsay Chag Casting Mars Feehery Production Design Chris Scharffenberg Set Decoration Lisa Norcia Costume Design