Rotten Tomatoes
Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes

Songs from the Hole

Play trailer Poster for Songs from the Hole 2024 1h 46m Documentary Drama Music Play Trailer Watchlist
Watchlist Tomatometer Popcornmeter
88% Tomatometer 8 Reviews Popcornmeter Fewer than 50 Ratings
At 15, he took a life. Three days later, his brother's life was taken. A moving chronicle of forgiveness, family, and the transformative power of art, SONGS FROM THE HOLE weaves music and storytelling into an innovative documentary visual album. Through clear-eyed narration and lyrical journal entries, incarcerated musician James "JJ'88" Jacobs reveals his innermost struggles as a person who has both committed and experienced violent harm. While serving a double-life prison sentence, he searches for healing and peace as he comes of age in this documentary-musical odyssey composed behind bars. In a unique creative process director Contessa Gayles (The Feminist on Cellblock Y, Founder Girls) collaborated with protagonist/writer JJ'88 and producer/music producer richie reseda to interweave the collective storytelling of the film's non-fiction participants, with imagined memories, dreams and spiritual dialogues set to JJ'88's original music. The result is a powerful mix of truth-telling and dreaming that reveal the potential for healing and liberation within us all.
Watch on Netflix Stream Now

Where to Watch

Songs from the Hole

Critics Reviews

View More
Lisa Kennedy New York Times Aug 14
Visually fluid and emotionally complex, the nonfiction hybrid Songs From the Hole, directed by Contessa Gayles, offers viewers their own portal: into James’s anguished reckoning, but also into bedeviling questions about crime, punishment and forgiveness. Go to Full Review
Daniel Fienberg The Hollywood Reporter 03/14/2024
A fresh and lyrical take on the genre. Go to Full Review
Todd Gilchrist Variety 03/13/2024
Co-writer and director Contessa Gayles combines nakedly vulnerable reflections from James "JJ'88" Jacobs with poetic recreations for a deeply affecting experience, both musically and dramatically. Go to Full Review
Brooke Obie Black Girl Watching Aug 24
Part documentary, part visual album, Songs from the Hole is a gorgeous meditation on healing toxic masculinity and breaking generational cycles. It’s thoughtful, it’s searing, it’s painful, and, just like abolition itself, well worth the effort. Go to Full Review
Jennifer Green Common Sense Media Aug 19
This creative documentary weaves together an array of storytelling methods to recount musician JJ'88's gripping but difficult journey of violence, despair, and redemption. Go to Full Review
Carla Renata The Curvy Film Critic 04/27/2024
Songs From The Hole simultaneously teaches the lesson of how music not only entertains, but literally can save lives and how faith is only as powerfully strong as you allow it to become. Go to Full Review
Read all reviews

Audience Reviews

View More
Robert H. @Rwhobbs198 Dec 25 Trouble in the Hole is a Netflix documentary that left me more frustrated than intrigued. While there are moments of creativity —particularly through the concept of writing from solitary confinement—the overall execution feels misguided. It drifts into territory that unintentionally glorifies the lifestyle and mindset surrounding incarceration rather than critically examining it. It struggles to maintain balance. Instead of offering deeper insight into the realities and consequences of that world, it leans into the mystique of it. That approach makes the subject matter harder to connect with and, difficult to respect. There are flashes of originality in the presentation, and the premise itself had potential. But it ultimately undermines what could have been a more thoughtful exploration of the topic. By the end, it’s a documentary that I personally found unlikeable and not particularly rewarding. Not one I’d recommend, and certainly not one I’d revisit. See more Carin Aug 17 This is a must see doc about faith, choices and true wonder of reflection See more S S Aug 14 Refreshingly original film both inspiring and moving while highlighting all the problems with the US justice system and all the terrible, frustrating & complex reasons 15 year old's like James end up there in the first place. It's a horrible mess. James epitomizes the importance of hope, growth and forgiveness. He is lucky to have such an amazingly supportive family. See more Debra B Aug 14 Captivating, redemptive, heartbreaking, uplifting, despairing, hopeful. What a roller coaster of emotions and through it all, I pray for James Jacob's victim family. I pray healing and forgiveness has come for them so that they may be free. See more Read all reviews
Songs from the Hole

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW
1-800-ON-HER-OWN % % 1-800-ON-HER-OWN Watchlist The Klezmer Project 100% 99% The Klezmer Project Watchlist TRAILER for The Klezmer Project Southern Gospel 100% 94% Southern Gospel Watchlist TRAILER for Southern Gospel Rewind 100% 96% Rewind Watchlist American Symphony 94% 74% American Symphony Watchlist Discover more movies and TV shows. View More

Movie Info

Synopsis At 15, he took a life. Three days later, his brother's life was taken. A moving chronicle of forgiveness, family, and the transformative power of art, SONGS FROM THE HOLE weaves music and storytelling into an innovative documentary visual album. Through clear-eyed narration and lyrical journal entries, incarcerated musician James "JJ'88" Jacobs reveals his innermost struggles as a person who has both committed and experienced violent harm. While serving a double-life prison sentence, he searches for healing and peace as he comes of age in this documentary-musical odyssey composed behind bars. In a unique creative process director Contessa Gayles (The Feminist on Cellblock Y, Founder Girls) collaborated with protagonist/writer JJ'88 and producer/music producer richie reseda to interweave the collective storytelling of the film's non-fiction participants, with imagined memories, dreams and spiritual dialogues set to JJ'88's original music. The result is a powerful mix of truth-telling and dreaming that reveal the potential for healing and liberation within us all.
Director
Contessa Gayles
Producer
Contessa Gayles, richie reseda, David Felix Sutcliffe
Screenwriter
Contessa Gayles, JJ'88, Contessa Gayles
Distributor
Netflix
Production Co
Impact Partners, Cocomotion Pictures, Artemis Rising Foundation
Genre
Documentary, Drama, Music
Original Language
English
Release Date (Streaming)
Aug 13, 2025
Runtime
1h 46m
Most Popular at Home Now