Rotten Tomatoes
Suggestions will appear as you start typing. Submit search Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes

The Craigslist Killer

Play trailer Poster for The Craigslist Killer TV-PG 2011 1h 30m Drama Play Trailer Watchlist
Watchlist Tomatometer Popcornmeter
Tomatometer 0 Reviews 31% Popcornmeter 500+ Ratings
Police suspect medical student Philip Markoff of murdering a young woman at a Boston hotel.
Watch on Fandango Stream Now

Where to Watch

The Craigslist Killer

Audience Reviews

View More
Caleb K @CalebTheMovieWatcher729 Oct 26, 2026 The motivations of Phillip are not made very clear by this movie which makes it hard to understand why he is doing what he is doing. I understand that this is based on a true story & that the motives of real killers are often never fully explained or understood, however this did not work from a movie storytelling perspective. The fact that he very clearly suffers some type mental disorder that is left vague & ill-defined only adds to the confusion. At times the film treats him like an ordinary sex addict, sometimes he appears to have a gambling addiction, & then at other times he is suffering from dizzy spells. Thus it is hard for the audience to understand exactly what he is suffering from. The second half of the film takes an odd storytelling direction tonally when the police are treated almost antagonistically and the movie seemingly tries to make us feel sympathetic or sad for the murderous rapist. This movie also feels way too long and could have easily been done in 45 minutes. See more
zoop S @zoopswishington Oct 26, 2026 It was totally confusing at the beginning what the main guy's deal was. In his POV, his vision keeps going blurry and it seems like he's having some sort of drug withdrawals or maybe a panic attack. Then it seems like he's a gambling addict? I couldn't figure out his motivation. I felt the movie was too long for the small bit of "story" there was and focused way too much on the "romantic" aspects and made it seem like we were supposed to feel sympathetic for the guy. The sad/romantic music as he committed suicide seemed really inappropriate. Also why did the detectives act so villain-like in some scenes? See more
Doganek T @RT86075535 Mar 18, 2026 I though the movie had a slow beginning but i lt turns out the whole movie was just bad. Wouldn't recommend it to anyone. See more
Aluna U @RT14704568 Sep 30, 2025 The Craigslist Killer offers an intriguing premise based on a true crime, but focuses more on romantic drama than psychological tension, leaving its thriller potential underexplored. Weak character development and a lack of emotional depth hinder the impact of its core message—that people can hide dark secrets behind perfect facades. Though the story is systematic, its rushed resolution and unclear tone make it fall short of its gripping potential. Read the full review here: (Indonesian version : alunauwie.com) and (English version : uwiepuspita.com) See more
Lucy B @RT05677314 Aug 26, 2025 Absolutely atrocious. I have literally set up an account on here to rate this film. It was like it was trying to be an episode of Dawson’s Creek with the most twee, polished crimes ever. This guy took/ruined people’s lives. I’m actually angry I spent so much time watching it until the end. Whatever you do, please do not watch this unbelievable rubbish. See more
Tom S @RT27222980 Apr 11, 2025 I set up an account to review this film. Would give zero if I could. Genuinely awful. It's based on a true story but it's like the director decided that the audience feel empathy towards the killer for from the beginning regardless of the fact it is based on a true story. From the romcom setup at the beginning to the feel good music when he's caught to, arguably the most disjointed, ridiculous ending to any piece of film ever. As an audience we are led down a path of a romantic story between killer and fiance breaking up and him ending his life in a way that he is portrayed as a martyr. We are expected, and encouraged, to forget he killed people (in real life!) Awful storytelling, awful direction. Genuinely made me think this film was made by a close family relative of the killer in question. Don't watch unless you have watched every other film made ever by anyone. See more
Read all reviews
The Craigslist Killer

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING

Movie Info

Synopsis Police suspect medical student Philip Markoff of murdering a young woman at a Boston hotel.
Director
Stephen Kay
Production Co
Silver Screen Pictures
Rating
TV-PG
Genre
Drama
Original Language
English
Release Date (Streaming)
Apr 16, 2012
Runtime
1h 30m
Join The Newsletter Join The Newsletter Cookie Settings