Matt Farnsworth Mike Director, Actor, Screenwriter, Producer, Cinematographer, Film Editing Diane Foster Audrey Actor, Producer David Backus The Orphan Killer Actor James McCaffrey Detective Jones Actor John Savage Detective Walker Actor Karen Young Sister Mary Actor Spencer List Young Marcus Actor Margot White Jenny Miller Actor Mike Doyle Marcus Miller Sr. Actor Ivan Martin Jim Actor Karen Olivo Angie Actor Matthew Arkin Bob Actor Charlotte Maier Sister Constance Actor Dana DeVestern Young Audrey Actor Aaron Medick Cinematographer Bullet Tooth Original Music Lee Yaniv Production Design Garrett Lowe Art Director Natalie Tyler Set Decoration Olivia Mori Costume Design Judy Henderson Casting