Blair Treu Director Katherine Heigl Alexia Wheaton Actor Danielle Harris Hayley Wheaton Actor Donnie Jeffcoat Kyle Harding Actor Scott Wilkinson Ben Wheaton Actor Mary Parker Williams Nan Wheaton Actor Lois Chiles Mittermonster Actor Ivey Lloyd Caitlin Sheinbaum Actor Matthew Barker Simon Actor Jacque Gray Kazumi Actor Kari Petersen Talley Actor January Sorensen Sabrina Actor Dane Stevens Mr. Frauenfleder Actor Mark Hofeling Mr. Watson Actor, Production Design Trevor Black Photographer Actor Emily Klindt Senior Class President Actor Andy West Panicked Boy Actor Trent Rockwood Boy 1 Actor Richard Grove Fan 1 Actor Josh James Senior Boy Actor Charles Metten Interview Man Actor Joyce Cohen Interview Woman Actor Kimi Encarnacion Band: Moonpools & Caterpillars Actor Jay Jay Encarnacion Band: Moonpools & Caterpillars Actor Gugut Salgado Band: Moonpools & Caterpillars Actor Tim Depala Band: Moonpools & Caterpillars Actor Jessica Barondes Screenwriter David C. Anderson Producer Don Schain Producer H.E. Scruggs Executive Producer Brian Sullivan Cinematographer David Blangsted Film Editing Ken Diamond Art Director Lawane Cole Costume Design Karen Margiotta Casting Mary Margiotta Casting