Jesse Palmer Host Wells Adams Self Greer Blitzer Contestant, Contestant, Contestant, Contestant, Contestant, Contestant, Contestant Aaron Bryant Contestant Peter Cappio Contestant Jessica "Jess" Girod Contestant Olivia Lewis Contestant Blake Moynes Contestant Mercedes Northup Contestant Rachel Recchia Contestant Kylee Russell Contestant Will Urena Contestant Brooklyn Willie Contestant Catherine "Cat" Wong Contestant Mike Fleiss Executive Producer Martin Hilton Executive Producer Nicole Woods Executive Producer Tim Warner Executive Producer Louis Caric Executive Producer Peter Geist Executive Producer