Gene Barry Bat Masterson Actor Richard Arlen John Minor Guest Star Susan Cummings Lili Napoleon Guest Star Don Kennedy Sheriff Tim Lockhart Guest Star John Holland Charming Charlie Griswold Guest Star Frank J. Scannell Gus Guest Star Fred Catania Albert Hastings Guest Star Kenneth Alton Deputy Ed Lauber Guest Star Ken Christy Eli Guest Star Jack LeMaire Det. Shorty Mason Guest Star Alan Crosland Jr. Director Paul Franklin Writer