Michael Weatherly Dr. Jason Bull Actor Freddy Rodríguez Benny Colón Actor Geneva Carr Marissa Morgan Actor Jaime Lee Kirchner Danny James Actor Annabelle Attanasio Cable McCrory Actor Chris Jackson Chunk Palmer Actor Sam Vartholomeos Adam Harris Guest Star Nell Verlaque Emily Connor Guest Star Brian Dystra Doug Harris Guest Star Rebecca Harris Sally Harris Guest Star Kevin Hale Courthouse Guard Guest Star Kim Sykes Judge Foley Guest Star Zack Ambramowitz Bailiff Guest Star John Speredakos Adam's Lawyer Guest Star Casey Ford Alexander Newsperson 1 Guest Star Liza Colón-Zayas ADA Jessica Goodman Guest Star Arnold Y. Kim Potential Juror 1 Guest Star Pamela Stewart Potential Juror 2 Guest Star Gadi Rubin Potential Juror 3 Guest Star Joe Grifasi Judge Rand Guest Star Lucy Taylor Dawn Connor Guest Star Matthew Lawler Nathan Connor Guest Star Nadia Quinn Ava's Mom Guest Star Izzy Hanson-Johnston Ava Simmons Guest Star Austin Ku Dr. James Muller Guest Star LeVera Sutton Jury Foreman Guest Star John Siciliano Harrison Guest Star Jenni Graham Juror 6 Guest Star Paul Attanasio Executive Producer Phil McGraw Executive Producer Jay McGraw Executive Producer Justin Falvey Executive Producer Darryl Frank Executive Producer Veronica West Writer Sarah Kucserka Writer Peter Werner Director