Michael Weatherly Dr. Jason Bull Actor Freddy Rodríguez Benny Colón Actor Geneva Carr Marissa Morgan Actor Jaime Lee Kirchner Danny James Actor Chris Jackson Chunk Palmer Actor MacKenzie Meehan Taylor Rentzel Actor Angelic Zambrana Jessica Lee Guest Star Cillian O'Sullivan Nathan Alexander Guest Star Aimee Mullins Alice Yarrow Guest Star J.C. MacKenzie Judge McPherson Guest Star Emma Kikue Tara Atkins Guest Star Paton Ashbrook Beth Alexander Guest Star Charles Dumas Older Man Guest Star Kevin Santiago Juror #12 Guest Star Cathy Trien Juror #24 Guest Star Billy Hepfinger Juror #28 Guest Star Gibson Frazier Dr. Benson Guest Star Paul Attanasio Executive Producer Phil McGraw Executive Producer Jay McGraw Executive Producer Justin Falvey Executive Producer Darryl Frank Executive Producer Travis Donnelly Writer Aaron Lipstadt Director