Christopher Crutchfield Walker Narrator Richard Cravens James Hataway Actor Lance Stroud Drug Dealer Actor Blake Burt Actor Jon Bielich Lloyd Bible Actor Conor Raney Steve Bechtel Actor John Farnworth Detective Stevens Actor Kenny Apel Randy Morgenson Actor Crystal Jasmine Day Bethany Decker Actor Paul Boffano John Paul Sr. Actor Alesia Burt Actor Ansley Gordon Tracy Ocasio Actor Carroll Burt Actor Doug Summers Randy Coffman Actor Camille Coladonato The Girl Who Got Away Actor Cyrus Crane Actor Charlie Dreizen Emile Decker Actor Raven Feather Ashley Freeman Actor John Honey Danny Freeman Actor Jenn Wright Lorene Bible Actor Knute Walker Executive Producer Eugenie Vink Executive Producer Sarah Hutt Producer, Director John Kelleran Cinematographer Eric Modena Film Editor Benjamin Ringe Executive Producer Steve Rivo Producer Elizabeth Fischer Executive Producer Annie Heringer Producer