Eric Stonestreet Host Danica McKellar Judge Steve Price Judge Joe Buck Narrator Michael Fantauzzo Contestant, Contestant Doug Pieschel Contestant Chris Wright Contestant Emma Renner Contestant Ben Tardif Contestant Nick Greene Contestant Michael Carrasquillo Contestant Derek Koops Contestant Alex Koops Contestant Rick Mascheck Contestant John Wickham Contestant Evan Voeltner Contestant Scott Sukot Contestant Niasia Williams Contestant Brianne Martin Contestant Gail Berman Executive Producer Danny Schrader Executive Producer Hend Baghdady Executive Producer