Eric Stonestreet Host Danica McKellar Judge Vernon Davis Judge Steve Price Judge Joe Buck Narrator Michael Fantauzzo Contestant, Contestant, Contestant Doug Pieschel Contestant Matt VanVleck Contestant Scott Cortus Contestant Nick Netta Contestant Elando Baltimore Contestant Chris Wright Contestant Emma Renner Contestant Ben Tardif Contestant Paul McCaffrey Contestant Jared Lyon Contestant James "Junior" Roth Contestant Nate Omaivboje Contestant Kayla Smart Contestant DiAngelo Soriano Contestant Kelly Tucker Contestant Ruby Houchens Contestant Luke Greenway Contestant Nick Greene Contestant Hugh Benjamin Contestant Michael Carrasquillo Contestant Breenae Washinton Contestant Derek Koops Contestant Lyle Broughton Contestant Alex Koops Contestant Gabe Dean Contestant Rachel Wess Contestant Tanek Ballachanda Contestant Gloria Robinson Contestant Robert Dehate Contestant Rick Mascheck Contestant John Wickham Contestant Kristine Kazian Contestant Brian Kazian Contestant Alex Nickel Contestant Victoria Bahary Contestant Nathan Heck Contestant Claudius Mbemba Contestant Evan Voeltner Contestant Stevens Cadet Contestant Paul Nelson Contestant Scott Sukot Contestant Greg Berkin Contestant Farah Bajwa Contestant Niasia Williams Contestant Brianne Martin Contestant Gail Berman Executive Producer Danny Schrader Executive Producer Hend Baghdady Executive Producer