Krysten Ritter Chloe Actor Dreama Walker June Actor Liza Lapira Robin Actor Mookie Blaiklock Eli Actor Eric André Mark Actor James Van Der Beek James Van Der Beek Actor Peter Mackenzie Guest Star Dean Cain Guest Star Hartley Sawyer Guest Star Eve Gordon Guest Star Nora Dunn Guest Star Shanti Lowry Guest Star Ray Ford Guest Star Tate Ellington Guest Star Jennie Pierson Guest Star Michael Croner Guest Star Rob Yang Guest Star Thushari Jayasekera Guest Star Donté Bonner Guest Star Katherine Tokarz Guest Star Nahnatchka Khan Executive Producer, Writer David Hemingson Executive Producer, Writer Jeffrey Morton Executive Producer Casey Johnson Writer Sally Bradford McKenna Writer Billy Finnegan Writer Corey Nickerson Writer David Windsor Writer Michael Alan Spiller Director Chris Koch Director Nanette Burstein Director Jason Winer Director, Executive Producer Wendey Stanzler Director